If you make a purchase after following a link on our site, we may earn a small commission. Learn more.

Critter Café review

Critter Café screenshot
Image: Sumo Digital/Secret Mode

A cute and cosy game that lets you run your own café and rescue little critters at the same time? Perfection! At least, that’s the impression that I initially got from Critter Café, a new sim game from Sumo Digital and Secret Mode. And after playing its Next Fest demo last month, I came away expecting this to be my new favourite cosy escape. Unfortunately, playing the full release of Critter Café hasn’t left me feeling quite so fulfilled.

Set in the picturesque world of Gold Leaf Isle, Critter Café sees you take the reins of a run-down café. Instantly you can rip out the old, broken furniture and replace it with a new, shiny decor, and open the doors to serve your first guests.

Serving guests in Critter Café isn’t a stressful Diner Dash-style affair. Instead of rushing around to make sure everyone gets a correct and timely order, you’ll need to complete a short minigame. Pouring a coffee means holding down a button for the right amount of time; decorating a latte involves a short rhythm game; cutting a cake means timing a couple of button presses just right; and serving food means completing an easy memory game.

It’s impossible to serve the wrong customer, as when you’re carrying food or drink you’re simply blocked from interacting with anyone else. And, as far as I can tell, you won’t be penalised for keeping customers waiting for too long – you’ll simply earn more experience points if you manage to serve more customers. It’s a rather simple and mindless task, and not all that fulfilling.

Critter Café screenshot
You’ll unlock more options to decorate your café the longer you play. Image: Sumo Digital/Secret Mode

Thankfully, there’s more to Critter Café than just serving coffee and cakes: the critters! At regular intervals you’ll receive a mysterious letter telling you that there’s a critter ready to be rescued. It first means exploring part of Gold Leaf Isle to find a portal, then going through to get the critter.

Related: The best relaxing games on Nintendo Switch

Inside each portal is a “dungeon” of sorts. Not that sort of dungeon, though: there’s no combat and no looting to be done here. Instead you’ll need to solve a puzzle. These start out like Sokoban-style block-pushing puzzles, where you’ll need to move blocks to a certain position in order to press forward. As you progress through the game, you’ll unlock new mechanics including a hammer that can destroy blocks of ice and a boomerang that can hit switches from a distance.

The puzzles get slightly trickier as you progress, then, and there certainly is a feeling of satisfaction involved in completing them. Of course, the reward for completing a dungeon is being able to rescue the critter and see it come to “work” in your café. You can also visit critters in their habitat and perform some basic interactions with them, like petting, throwing a toy and bathing them.

Critter Café screenshot
The block puzzles to rescue critters are engaging, even if they don’t gel all that well with the rest of the game. Image: Sumo Digital/Secret Mode

There are some great ideas here — but I think that’s part of the problem. Critter Café’s ideas don’t all quite gel together, and as a result it feels rather underbaked and underwhelming. While the idea of running a café and rescuing cute, fuzzy critters sounds like a great idea, those two functions aren’t exactly fully integrated. Sure, you can have a couple of your critters run around your café while you work, but other than getting in your way, they never really do much. You won’t see them interact with guests — except in specific cutscenes — and even if you place critter-specific furniture such as beds, climbing frames and scratching posts, you won’t see them use them.

There’s no real sense of development, either. You’ll gain experience as you keep playing, and by having your critters complete a shift in the café with you, your relationship with them will level up, but it doesn’t exactly mean much. Critters may gain passive skills, like not draining energy as quickly, but ultimately you won’t really notice them. As for your own levelling up, you’ll unlock new decorations for your café — and while it’s fun to decorate, it serves no purpose other than to satisfy your own need for style.

I really wanted more from Critter Café, but without any real narrative and no strong sense of purpose or progression, I quickly got bored of my time with the game. Running the café isn’t very fulfilling, and while completing the puzzles to rescue the critters is fun enough, if I want puzzles there are much better options out there. That’s not to say this is a bad game: it is cute, and there is fun to be had — it could just have been so much better.

Critter Café Review

Critter Café has lots of great ideas, but none of them really gel together all that well. Working in your café is tiresome, and while the puzzles involved in rescuing critters are fulfilling, the critters themselves have little purpose other than being cute. It all feels like a wasted opportunity.
5
out of 10

We like…

  • It's effortlessly cute
  • Decorating your café is fun, even if it has no purpose
  • Critter rescue puzzles are engaging

We don’t like…

  • Everything feels rather meaningless
  • Café management is basic at best
  • Critters are sorely under-utilised

This review of Critter Café is based on the PC version of the game, with a code provided by the publisher. It’s available on PC and Switch.

Similar Posts