Probably Stolen review – Cyberpunk shopkeeping is a busy job

Running a shop in a dystopian cyberpunk age isn’t for the weak of heart. You’ve got people trying to trade you counterfeit goods, security asking you to keep an eye out for criminals, slum-dwellers begging for food, and the threat of factions turning against you if you don’t help them out in the right way. You can’t possibly please everyone, then, and choosing exactly how to run your shop is what makes Probably Stolen so compelling.
Set on the lower levels of a space station, you’ll start out your Probably Stolen career selling just about anything you can get your hands on. Tinned food, bottles of water, scrap metal that can be used for crafting, household goods such as toilet paper and toothpaste. You know, the essentials. Not every item is so harmless, though; it won’t be long until you’re able to trade in weapons and contraband if you want – and of course, that’s where the real money is.
But you don’t have to do that. Probably Stolen gives you the freedom to specialise in whatever you want, and shape how your shop turns out. Right from the off you can choose a specialism if you want, although if it’s your first time playing, the game recommends you choose ‘apprentice’, which will let you get to grips with all of the systems on offer to you.
And there are a lot of systems. Probably Stolen is far more than just a shop simulator, as you can also craft items yourself, offer appraisal services, head out scavenging in an evening, and a whole lot more. It can be quite overwhelming, in fact, and when you first start playing, you’ll find various notes and bits of information left for you pretty much every new in-game day. Your box of notes will soon be overflowing and you’ll find yourself referring to them multiple times in a day.

Once you get your head around it, though, getting stuck into the day-to-day nitty-gritty of Probably Stolen is a real joy. At a basic level, you’ll need to sort out your inventory (space is limited, with a Resident Evil-style grid to organise your stock), sell customers the items they want and buy in new items from traders. But things get more complex when you start considering counterfeit goods, haggling for better prices, appeasing different factions who are all demanding different things from you, and a whole lot more.
Early on, a security guard passes you a list of ‘Most Wanted’. See any one of these people come to your shop and you’re told to push the ‘alert’ button under your counter immediately. You’ll get a nice reward, job done. Right? But maybe the space station security aren’t everything they say they are. Maybe these most wanted individuals are simply trying to make a living. And maybe there’s more to gain by keeping them on your side rather than handing them over to the authorities. That’s your call to make.
I love that Probably Stolen puts you in moral situations like this, and while it’s not always clear-cut what is the right or wrong decision to make, that’s sort of the point. You’ll undoubtedly make some choices that you’ll come to regret – but isn’t that just real life? You’ll have to live with them, learn from them, and do whatever you can to repair your reputation, keep making money, and keep your shop running to the best of your ability.

I also love how hands-on Probably Stolen is. There are elements of the likes of Papers, Please here, with you needing to carefully scan packaging and labels to make sure you aren’t unknowingly buying counterfeit or fraudulent items. When it comes to appraising items for other customers, you’ll be given something like a robot arm and, using a handy guide, you’ll be checking for various features to work out how much it’s worth. They’re tasks requiring concentration and attention to detail, and while missing something important isn’t game over, it could have repercussions for your reputation.
There’s an awful lot of playability here, and with different ways to approach situations, it’s the type of game that will keep you coming back time and time again. Developer Questing Goose Studio has done an incredible job of creating a rich and varied experience that goes far beyond your standard shopkeeping simulator. Ensuring your shelves are stocked is just the beginning here; it’s everything else you need to think about that makes Probably Stolen so good.
Probably Stolen Review
We like…
- Looks great
- Gameplay is very involved and varied
- Much more than your standard shopkeeping sim
We don’t like…
- Some players might find it a little too complex
This review of Probably Stolen has been facilitated with a game code provided by the publisher. It’s available on PC.






