If you make a purchase after following a link on our site, we may earn a small commission. Learn more.

The Best Games Like Dark Souls on Xbox

The Best Games like Dark Souls on Xbox

FromSoftware’s Dark Souls series – and its other soulslike games – are some of the most popular games in the entirety of games media. Bloodborne, Elden Ring; we just can’t get enough of their tough-as-nails gameplay and thrilling, rich worlds. But what if you’ve seen everything they all have to offer and want something similar? Well, all is not lost: we’ve rounded up the best games like Dark Souls on Xbox.

We can’t say, hand-on-heart, that any of these games are quite as good as Dark Souls. But they do all scratch a similar itch, offering Soulslike RPG gameplay, engaging fantasy worlds and deep combat that requires skill and patience. And if you’re looking for a rewarding challenge, we think you’ll find it in our selection of the best Xbox games like Dark Souls.

More good stuff on Xbox

1. Elden Ring

Elden Ring- best games like Dark Souls
Image: FromSoftware/Bandai Namco

Just what sort of list of games like Dark Souls on Xbox would this be if we didn’t include Elden Ring? A bad one, that’s what. Yes, it’s an obvious starting place: made by the same development team, Elden Ring is the closest thing you’re going to get to Dark Souls in just about every way. Its combat is similar, its focus on player-led exploration is similar, and its gorgeous, deadly, deep-fantasy world is similar, too.

But also, it’s probably better. Yes, Elden Ring may well be better than all the Dark Souls games put together. It may well be the best thing that FromSoftware has made so far. If you’ve exhausted the Dark Souls trilogy and somehow haven’t stumbled your way onto Elden Ring yet, get it rectified. You’ll love every moment of it.

Read our review of Elden Ring

2. Lies of P

Lies of P 1 (1)
Image: Neowiz

One of the newest games on this list, Lies of P is well worth your time if you’re looking for one of the best games like Dark Souls on Xbox. Its story is loosely based on the tale of Pinocchio, but this may well be the darkest retelling of the classic story yet. What’s most likely to grab you about Lies of P is its gorgeous, otherworldly Victorian setting – it reminds us very much of Bloodborne, another of From Software’s games. And since Bloodborne is exclusive to PlayStation, it’s just about the closest thing you’re going to get on Xbox.

Despite not being made by From Software, Lies of P is about the closest thing you’re going to get to Dark Souls from a different developer. Some may consider it derivative, but it still has plenty of its own original ideas that make it an adventure well worth jumping into.

Read our review of Lies of P

3. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Image: FromSoftware/Activision

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is another game from Dark Souls developer FromSoftware, but it leans in a very different direction than Elden Ring. Well, almost. It may have a very different combat system, and you may not be able to level up your character in order to give yourself more of a fighting chance, but it still has much of the appeal of a Dark Souls game.

For one, it’s got a beautiful but hostile world – one that begs to be explored but presents danger around every corner. And it also features epic bosses that will require you to use every bit of your skill to overcome. Its set apart by its unique setting, which looks beautiful – particularly if you’re playing on Xbox One X or Series X. If you want a game like Dark Souls that will truly test your abilities, this is the one.

Read our review of Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice

4. Lords of the Fallen

Lords of the Fallen
Image: Hexworks/CI Games

Don’t confuse this Lords of the Fallen with the Lords of the Fallen that released on Xbox One back in 2014. Although they share a name and a developer, these two games couldn’t be further apart in terms of quality of gameplay. You might consider it to be a remake of the original, but it’s best to consider it a completely different game altogether. Released in 2023, it’s one of the best games like Dark Souls you can play on Xbox, and we loved every moment we spent with the game.

It shares some things in common with Dark Souls, of course. Its combat is familiar, as is its dark, fantastical setting. But it has plenty of its own tricks up its sleeve, including a mechanic that allows you to visit another realm known as the Land of the Dead. It adds depth to exploration and another layer of challenge – you see, it’s not so easy to get out of the Land of the Dead once you’re there. It’s not the only unique thing that Lords of the Fallen has to offer fans of Dark Souls, either, but we recommend you simply play it to find out the rest.

Read our review of Lords of the Fallen

5. Code Vein

Code Vein
Image: Bandai Namco

On the surface, Code Vein looks like Dark Souls with anime vampires. It’s true, to a degree. But dig a little deeper and you’ll find that there’s actually much more to it. While the weightlessness of your character’s movement and attacks will initially throw you off, persist with Code Vein and you’ll discover a game that’s really rewarding. You can change Blood Codes at the drop of a hat, granting you access to different combat options without having to start the game again as a new character. And skills within Blood Codes can be mastered and carried over to others, too, allowing you to create your very own playstyle.

Code Vein also has a much simpler approach to telling its story, which eventually grabs your attention like a vice. Throw in sumptuous visuals, a wonderful soundtrack and one hell of a character creator, and you have a souls-like that’s familiar in all the good ways while offering up some welcome new features. So, if you’re after one of the best games like Dark Souls on Xbox and don’t mind the anime aesthetic, be sure to give Code Vein a go.

Read our review of Code Vein

6. The Surge 2

The Surge 2
Image: Deck 13

The Surge 2 improves on its predecessor in every way, and The Surge wasn’t exactly a bad game. In fact, it was very good indeed. But its sequel is even better. Taking the Dark Souls formula and implanting it in a sci-fi setting, The Surge 2 is quite possibly the best souls-like available outside those that FromSoftware have put out.

Its combat is tense and weighty, there’s a decent amount of scope for multiple character builds, and its setting is cohesive and unique. Plus, how many games let you rip off parts of your enemies so you can use them yourself? The Surge 2 allows that, and it’s great. If you’re a fan of the Dark Souls games you really should add The Surge 2 to your library – it’s as simple as that. And if you haven’t played the first game, that’s worth playing as well.

Read our review of The Surge 2

7. Blasphemous 2

Blasphemous 2
Image: The Game Kitchen/Team 17

While Blasphemous 2 is perhaps better described as a metroidvania than a Soulslike, you can tell it’s been heavily inspired by Dark Souls. Playing as The Penitent One, Blasphemous 2 is as intriguing as it is punishing. You’ll make your way through atmospheric environments, avoiding perilous traps and combating vile enemies. And if you want to succeed, you need to find shrines and altars that allow you to increase your health, improve the strength of your sword, and grant you more fervour. If you’ve played the first game, you’ll know what to expect. If you haven’t? You can jump in here, sure, but we’d recommend starting with the first Blasphemous. It’s just as good.

There’s a lot to like about Blasphemous 2. Its dark, foreboding atmosphere instantly sucks you in, but it’s the often-gargantuan bosses that truly make the game worth playing. They’re tough but fair, and overcoming them feels like a true achievement. Needless to say, if you enjoy the challenging boss encounters in Dark Souls, you’re going to love the Blasphemous games.

Read our review of Blasphemous 2

8. Remnant: From the Ashes

Remnant From the Ashes
Gunfire Games/Gearbox Publishing

If you’ve ever wondered what Dark Souls with guns would be like, you need to try Gunfire Games’ Remnant: From the Ashes. Journeying across multiple areas to reach a mysterious tower, the enemies you face in Remnant: From the Ashes are challenging. Or at least they are in numbers. At range you’ll need to make use of firearms to dispatch them effectively, but when up close you’ll probably find that your melee weapon is more suitable. And to avoid incoming attacks you’re going to have to do some well-timed dodging.

It’s the bosses that truly test your skills, though. They’re massive, have loads of HP and perform devastating attacks. They frequently summon in fodder to make fighting them a little more tricky, too. But if you emerge victorious you’ll obtain some valuable materials that allow you to craft some interesting equipment. Be sure to check Remnant: From the Ashes out if you’re looking for one of the best games like Dark Souls on Xbox, but want a bit of a twist on the formula. When you’re done with it, you can also jump into its sequel, too.

Read our review of Remnant: From the Ashes